It should be clear in context that all commentaries are a reaction to a particular paper. Do not summarize the focal article; just give the reference.
Hence, authors should select a few target journals in advance to ensure that in case the paper is rejected by one journal, it can be sent to the next without further loss of time.
Use a short title that emphasizes your key message. However, they are definitely an immense value-addition to the existing plethora of scientific literature. If your topic is about controversial advances in medicine, your commentary will be slanted toward doctors and other professionals in the medical field and your goal will be to provide a commentary that will encourage these professionals to view the subject in a way other than initially presented.
While a commentary may be critical of a focal article, it is important to maintain a respectful tone that is critical of ideas, not of authors.
A commentary is a comment on a newly published article. The objective of the commentary is carefully associated with the real reason for writing a commentary. Going as light as possible on references provides more space for commentaries. The goal of publishing commentaries is to advance the research field by providing a forum for varying perspectives on a certain topic under consideration in the journal.
Implications of the proposed ideas or opinions are discussed, future directions for research are proposed, and drawbacks or limitations are mentioned. Preparing to write Decide the most suitable type of article for the message you wish to convey whether you are writing a scholarly article, describing an innovation, or offering your opinions or ideas in a perspective.
However, some journals specifically mention that abstracts are not required. Make sure there is full author info name, affiliation, address, phone, email for all authors. It will be clear in context that all commentaries are a reply to a particular paper.
Make sure there is full author information name, affiliation, address, phone, email for all authors. There is a tendency for commentators to want to start with a paragraph or two of general praise before getting down to business. Use these simple guidelines: A tightly argued page commentary is likely to be better received than a meandering 10 page commentary.
A small set of reviewers will read and evaluate all commentaries as they need to compare commentaries for issues of redundancy and to make evaluations of relative merit.
An application of a theoretical or methodological perspective that sheds light on the issues addressed in the focal article.
Reviewers need to compare commentaries for issues of redundancy and to make evaluations of relative merit e. Steps Edit Part 1 of three: For commentary purposes, cite only works absolutely essential to support your point.
We now welcome commentaries. Given these demands on reviewers, the level of detail of reviewer comments will typically be far less than that received for typical journal submission. Your commentary should be between four and six double-spaced pages, plus a title page.
If you have any doubts or questions, you can post them in the comments section below. This is driven by journal production schedules. We now welcome commentaries.
Does the book deserve more attention or less attention than the public is giving it. Perspective pieces may focus on current advances and future directions on a topic, and may include original data as well as personal opinion.
Do not summarize the focal article. Sometimes, you might be given apparent laws and regulations and rules and rules to look at. A commentary may be: Authors should also keep in mind that some journals publish these articles by invitation only, and it is best to send a pre-submission inquiry to journals that state that they do not accept unsolicited submissions.
The introduction provides background information and usually includes a brief review of the literature. A critical challenge to one or more aspects of the focal article, arguing for a position other than that taken in the focal article.
It is possible that two authors may submit highly similar commentaries. Commentary essays are written independent of the essay they are covering but act as an extension of the original essay and topic.
Are you currently presently presently critiquing student work. Queries for the Editor: Persuade your readers to look at the original topic from your perspective, but do not force them to do it.
We must know who the authors are, and the authors must assign copyright to SIOP prior to publication. Perspective, opinion, and commentary articles are scholarly articles which express personal opinion or a new perspective about existing research on a particular topic.
Perspectives, opinion pieces, and commentaries are some short scholarly article types that journals publish. A commentary essay, usually aimed at an academic audience, strives to help its audience make sense of a topic covered in another essay or article.
Commentary essays are written critically and formally, with objective and subjective standpoints. Literature commentary has some rules: • do not use I, me, my, we, us, • avoid using would, should, could, mayor might Literature commentary discusses what the concrete detail shows about a character or event in a story.
If you get stuck writing commentary, start your commentary sentences with This shows that _ The result will almost always be commentary.
MELAB Sample Essays and Commentary 1 Contents On the following pages are ten MELAB essays representative of each score on the MELAB Writing Rating Scale. Commentaries follow each sample essay.
A condensed version of the rating scale is available on page MELAB Sample Essays and Commentary 1 Contents On the following pages are ten MELAB essays representative of each score on the MELAB Writing Rating Scale. Commentaries follow each sample essay.
A condensed version of the rating scale is available on page A commentary essay, usually aimed at an academic audience, strives to help its audience make sense of a topic covered in another essay or article.
Commentary essays are written critically and formally, with objective and subjective standpoints.Writing a commentary on an article